Categories: LocalMoney

Sabina O’Donnell murder case raises questions about suspect’s intelligence

A jury has begun deliberating in the murder trial of 20-year-old Donte Johnson, who stands of accused in the rape and murder of Sabina Rose O’Donnell near Fourth and Girard two years ago.

O’Donnell, 20, was found naked in a lot outside her apartment in June 2010. Two weeks later, Johnson was identified and surrendered to police and allegedly confessed to the crime. Both sides yesterday presented their final arguments to the jury.

One of Johnson’s attorneys, Gary Server, said several tests show that Johnson functions on a grade-school level and that his statement to police was false.

“He’s a kid. He’s not thinking like you and I,” Server said. “He would’ve said anything to get out of there, and he did.”

Server also told jurors the DNA evidence in this case is flawed. He also questioned why two brown hairs found on O’Donnell’s body were not tested.

“Why don’t we have that evidence? I don’t know why we don’t have that evidence.”

Assistant District Attorney Richard Sax said Johnson ruthlessly attacked O’Donnell, not for her bike, but to rape her.

“He took everything from her — her dignity, her womanhood, her freedom, her life,” Sax said.

He called the DNA evidence, which included Johnson’s sperm found on Sabina, more than reliable. He also pointed to surveillance video which appears to show Johnson riding his bicycle in the area around the time of the crime.

Sax also referred to a medical examiner’s testimony that O’Donnell was strangled with her bra for three to five minutes, indicating Johnson intended to kill O’Donnell so that she could not identify him.

The jury will continue deliberations today. Johnson is charged with first-degree murder, rape, robbery and other charges. If convicted of first-degree murder, he will receive a mandatory life sentence.

Memory questions

A central issue in the case was whether Johnson had the capacity to understand the statement he gave to police and whether his final version of what happened was ultimately the truth.

Johnson’s attorney, Gary Server, blamed the variations in Johnson’s accounts on an impaired memory.

“He tells five different stories. … There are reasons why he’s incapable of telling the truth. His memory is impaired,” Server said during closing arguments before the case was handed over to the jury. Assistant District Attorney Richard Sax claimed that Johnson had no trouble recalling the details for detectives.

“Everything about this case was visual. You don’t forget what you did to that girl,” Sax said, looking at Johnson. “And you never will.”

Metro Philadelphia

Recent Posts

Saquon Barkley responds to Giants fan calling him a traitor, says he ‘went to the organization he felt was best’

It seems like eliminating the Sixers from the playoffs just isn’t enough for your regular…

2 mins ago

Ranger Suarez awarded NL Pitcher of the Month after an incredible month of April

The Philadelphia Phillies were among the hottest teams in baseball during the month of April.…

1 hour ago

Eagles rookie jersey numbers revealed: Jeremiah Trotter Jr. takes on his Father’s old number

The Philadelphia Eagles started their Friday morning with some good vibes, revealing the jersey numbers…

2 hours ago

Deaths at the Kentucky Derby bring changes ahead of the 150th edition at Churchill Downs

By BETH HARRIS AP Racing Writer Memories are made at the Kentucky Derby, most of them…

5 hours ago

Sixers eliminated after dropping Game 6 to the Knicks

Facing elimination, the Philadelphia 76ers took to their home court after a thrilling stand in…

13 hours ago

Revised Bus Revolution plan set to go for SEPTA board approval this month

The Bus Revolution plan has been finalized, and SEPTA’s board, which previously put off a…

21 hours ago

This website uses cookies.