Metro Philly Sports Network Logo

Which prospects should the Phillies protect ahead of the Rule 5 deadline?

Bryan Rincon seems to be an automatic choice for the Phillies, but who else can join him on the 40-man roster?

Posted

The Philadelphia Phillies have some decisions to make when it comes to who they will protect on their 40-man roster, with the protection deadline coming on Tuesday. 

With the deadline slated for 6 p.m., players who signed at the age of 18 or younger must be added to their organization’s 40-man roster within five seasons, while those who inked a deal at 19 or older must be added within four seasons. 

Those players who are not chosen to be protected are subject to becoming eligible for the Rule 5 Draft, where another organization can draft them but is required to keep the player on its major league roster for the following season. 

At the time of writing, the Phillies have 38 players on their 40-man roster so without having to make additional roster moves, Dave Dombrowski and the front office could protect at least two players in that scenario.

While there is uncertainty surrounding the Rule 5 Draft itself with MLB’s collective bargaining agreement expiring on Dec. 1 and a potential lockout could prevent the big league portion of the draft from happening. 

Nonetheless, here are some prospects that could be protected by the Phillies: 

Bryan Rincon, SS 

This is a no-brainer. After enjoying a breakout season with Double-A Reading, the team’s No. 4 prospect, according to MLB Pipeline has as much momentum and hype around any prospect in the system and in baseball. 

The 22-year-old switch-hitter who was praised for his defensive skills had the bat catch up to his glove in a big way this past season. 

In 118 games, he slashed .267/.410/.517 with a .927 OPS along with 26 home runs, 67 RBIs and 30 stolen bases, setting career-highs in nearly every key offensive statistic. 

Thanks to his impressive campaign, he was named the Phillies’ Paul Owens Award winner as the organization’s top minor league position player. 

Primarily playing shortstop, Rincon will undoubtedly be protected. While he will have a chance to potentially make the team out of spring training, Rincon can now be viewed as a potential candidate to be the team’s shortstop of the future, with Aidan Miller seeing more time at third base and questions surrounding Trea Turner’s ability to play the position defensively moving forward. 

Wen-Hui Pan, RHP  

Armed with a devastating splitter, Pan had a relatively encouraging 2026 campaign making his way back from Tommy John surgery forcing him to miss all of the 2025 season. 

The right-hander worked his way up three levels in the system, appearing in 38 games and posting a 3.10 ERA with 48 strikeouts in 40 ⅔ innings. He also notched six saves. 

The Taiwanese product also represented the Phillies in the All-Star Futures Game held at Citizens Bank Park over the summer. 

What makes the 20th-ranked prospect intriguing is that prior to his injury, he touched triple digits occasionally with his fastball, while consistently reaching the upper 90s this season. While his command can elude him at times, that can also be a benefit, as he has good enough stuff to fool hitters out of the zone. 

However, he has yet to pitch above the Double-A level, so continuing to miss bats will be key for his development. 

If he can continue to shake the rust off, he could potentially be a bullpen arm that can be serviceable at the big-league level, making him a leader in the clubhouse behind Rincon for that second and final 40-man spot if the Phillies decide not to open more up. 

Mavis Graves, LHP

Another pitcher who could possibly surprise some and get protected is the southpaw in Graves. 

Finishing up his age 22 season, the No. 26 prospect put a rough start to the season in High-A Jersey Shore where he posted a 4.78 ERA in 58 ⅓ innings in the starting rotation behind him and thrived in a bullpen role with Double-A Reading. Over his final 13 regular season appearances, he did not allow an earned run over 17 ⅔ innings to go with 29 punchouts. 

Despite not having overpowering stuff when it comes to velocity, Graves’ ability to spin his secondary pitches helped him rack up 117 total strikeouts to just 43 walks. His 34.8% strikeout percentage was a career-best as well. 

His late-season transition to the pen could provide a quicker route to the major leagues with teams, including the Phillies, seemingly always looking for bullpen help in the offseason and during the regular season. 

With the Phillies searching for left-handed help in a market that isn’t flush with top-tier talent outside of Adrián Morejón, Graves could potentially be an inexpensive in-house option to keep around to let him continue to develop in Triple-A Lehigh Valley this upcoming season. 

Aroon Escobar, INF 

After a banner 2025 season, Escobar was unable to replicate the same success as one of the youngest players in Double-A Reading this season. 

At just 21, the infielder hit .230 with a .332 on-base percentage and a .347 slugging percentage while posting a .679 OPS, his lowest mark in his career since a 33-game season in the Dominican Summer League as an 18-year-old. 

The Phillies sent him to the Arizona Fall League for additional development. He played alongside fellow top prospects in Miller and Dante Nori where he slashed .250/.383/.375 with a pair of stolen bases. 

Escobar’s youth and tools make him an intriguing prospect and he currently ranks sixth in the system per MLB Pipeline. He has some versatility defensively, seeing time at second, third and first base. 

While he needs more time to develop, keeping Escobar around wouldn’t be the worst decision for the Phillies. He can be used as a potential trade chip down the road, especially if he returns to his 2025 form. 

Other Notable Players on the Outside: 

Raylin Heredia, OF 

Teetering on the edge of being a Top 30 prospect for the system, the 23-year-old enjoyed one of his best seasons as a pro, helping Reading win an Eastern League title. 

With a slash line of .278/.317/.473, he put together a 20/20 season, smacking 23 homers and stealing 25 bases while driving in 74 runs. He paced Reading with his 151 hits on the season, but his swing-and-miss profile is certainly cause for some concern. 

He whiffed 147 times while drawing just 25 walks across 577 plate appearances in Reading. 

Keaton Anthony, 1B 

A slugging corner infielder, primarily playing first base, Anthony’s calling card is his bat. 

With a career .314 batting average and .863 OPS in four seasons in the minor leagues, there’s little doubt that when Anthony connects on a pitch, he can hit it a long way. The 25-year-old has more gap-to-gap power, evident by his 68 career doubles to 29 career home runs. 

Anthony is blocked by Bryce Harper for the foreseeable future and with the Phillies without a top-30 first base prospect as it stands, there’s a chance that if he doesn’t get scooped up by another team, the Phillies bring him back to serve as depth at that position. 

Juan Villavicencio, SS

The 21-year-old infielder is the No. 19 prospect in the system and was finally able to show off his tools after struggling to get acclimated as a pro when he signed as an international free agent in 2022. 

He hit .271 with an .836 OPS in a career-high 103 games where he hit 20 doubles, seven triples and 14 home runs. 

Villavicencio has some untapped power potential that, if other teams don’t pick him up, the Phillies could keep in the mix. 

Phillies, Bryan Rincon, Dave Dombrowski, Rule 5 Draft, Aroon Escobar, Mavis Graves, Wen-Hui Pan, Anthony Keaton, MLB