Metro Philadelphia Logo

Trump administration reopen antisemitism investigation into Philly schools

Federal officials question the district's compliance with a 2024 settlement, while school leaders push back against the allegations.

Posted

President Donald Trump’s Department of Education has reopened an antisemitism probe into the School District of Philadelphia.

The department’s Office for Civil Rights, or OCR, announced late Monday afternoon that it had begun a “compliance review… based on credible reports that the district foments a hostile and unsafe learning environment for Jewish students.”

Federal officials allege that the district may not be complying with a settlement reached with OCR two years ago, in the final days of the Biden administration. The agreement required the district to retrain employees, improve recordkeeping procedures and review all recent reports of antisemitic discrimination and harassment, among other commitments.

A spokesperson said that the district is “very disappointed” in the department’s decision, “particularly since the District has been keeping OCR apprised of our significant efforts to implement the Voluntary Resolution Agreement and combat antisemitism and all forms of hate in our schools.”

“We reiterate that antisemitism has no place in our schools, and we take concerns about antisemitic harassment or discrimination very seriously,” the statement continued. “The District does not tolerate harassment or discrimination against any ethnic, racial or religious group, or against any protected class. We remain committed to fostering a safe and welcoming environment for all of our students and staff." 

The Louis D. Brandeis Center for Human Rights Under Law, a legal nonprofit that works to combat antisemitism, submitted a request to OCR on Oct. 30, seeking the compliance review.

“Our submission described teachers using classroom materials and school-related social media to glorify terrorism and promote hostility toward Jewish and Israeli students, including one teacher’s endorsement of spitting in the faces of ‘Zionist pigs,’” the organization posted on X, formerly Twitter. “We reported that some students concealed their Jewish identities and that the District failed to take effective action despite repeated notice.”

OCR’s announcement refers to a Congressional report published less than a month ago that examines alleged anti-Jewish bias in Philadelphia public schools,  California’s Berkeley Unified School District and the National Education Association, a teachers’ union.

The U.S. House Committee on Education and Workforce found that the district’s curricula “promote ideology justifying violent resistance and legitimize radical groups that incite antisemitism” and “train students, as early as second grade, to be far-left activists.” Teachers and staff are also accused of spreading antisemitism.

Rather than focusing on individual complaints of harassment or discrimination from Jewish students, the document primarily focuses on curriculum and materials offered to pupils.

For example, a unit in the district’s world history curriculum directs students to “honor” a resistance movement, according to the report. One of the options listed, the committee found, was the Great March of Return, a protest movement in Gaza that was endorsed by Hamas.

Board of Education President Reginald Streater said he and his colleagues disagreed with the conclusions of the report, while Monique Braxton, a district spokesperson, said the document contains “blatantly partisan framing” that “distorts and mischaracterizes our record.”

The report, at times, strays from antisemitism toward frequent conservative punching bags, including claims that the district embraces critical race theory and instructs students about alternative pronoun usage, environmental justice and critiques of capitalism.

Superintendent Tony Watlington Sr., in an interview with the U.S. House committee in September, disclosed that he had moved to fire the district’s social studies curriculum director, Ismael Jimenez. Jimenez is legally challenging his termination, the Inquirer reported.

Additionally, Watlington said he intends to standardize the social studies curriculum, removing control from teachers and district administrators in favor of national experts, the Congressional document states.

Watlington also told the committee that his human resources team has begun reviewing all antisemitism complaints filed since 2024, including those that deal with social media posts.

The House report faults Watlington for not definitively saying that it is antisemitic to claim that the State of Israel is a racist endeavor.

District officials pointed to an excerpt from the interview transcript in which he affirms that it is antisemitic to call for or justify the killing of Jews and to deny the Jewish people a “right to self-determination.”

In response to the “racist endeavor” question, he said, “Certainly a teacher has no business taking a point of view in a classroom. But I also think that might depend on circumstances and context relative to First Amendment freedoms of speech.”


MORE: Pro-Israel counterprotesters overwhelm Palestine bike ride boycott in Philly


School District of Philadelphia, Antisemitism, Donald Trump, Department of Education, Philadelphia Schools, Education, Civil Rights