Categories: LocalMoney

Stunning mistrial in CBP murder case

Lawyers for three men accused in the 2009 beating death of a Phillies fan outside Citizens Bank Park are expected to ask that the charges be dropped one day after the judge declared a mistrial.

Common Pleas Court Judge Shelley Robins New ruled that the prosecutor did not disclose to the defense that a witness would make an identification after Ryan Tulino made a surprise revelation on Monday when he identified Francis Kirchner as the man who delivered the fatal kick to David Sale’s head. New said the “blurt out” created a situation where the assistant district attorney might have to take the stand to undercut his own witness.

The attorneys are expected to reconvene today to discuss a retrial date, but the defense attorneys claim that would constitute double jeopardy.

Assistant District Attorney Richard Sax said it was the first time in 31 years as a prosecutor he’d had a mistrial declared during a trial.

“I respect the court, but I disagree completely with the necessity of a mistrial,” Sax said. Kirchner is charged with first-degree murder. Charles Bowers and James Groves are charged with third-degree murder.

Metro Philadelphia

Recent Posts

Philadelphia choses the ‘Italian’ as it’s favorite hoagie according to Metro poll

National Hoagie Day has now come and gone, and as folks around the country enjoyed…

14 mins ago

Homeless services budget hearing touches on Kensington sweep, new ‘wellness’ center

Representatives from the Office of Homeless Services were back before City Council on Monday, trying…

1 hour ago

Daryl Morey is ‘excited to attack’ offseason; hopes to begin new era of continuity

Philadelphia 76ers president of basketball operations Daryl Morey addressed the media Monday afternoon from the…

2 hours ago

The Eagles are in safe hands thanks to a new generation of leaders despite the end of an era on the horizon

The Philadelphia Eagles kickstarted their offseason workouts this past weekend by hosting rookie minicamp down…

2 hours ago

One natural gas transport plan killed in New Jersey as another forges ahead

By WAYNE PARRY Associated Press A major pipeline that would have moved natural gas through…

2 hours ago

Pennsylvania nurse who gave patients lethal or possibly lethal insulin doses gets life in prison

By BRUCE SHIPKOWSKI Associated Press A Pennsylvania nurse who administered lethal or potentially lethal doses…

3 hours ago

This website uses cookies.