Our favorite hoagies for the 25th annual Wawa Hoagie Day

Jennifer Logue

When your schedule is jam-packed and there’s not much time to think about lunch, it’s a beautiful thing to know you can always go to Wawa. Philadelphians have a lot of love for this east coast convenience store chain with their plethora of on-the-go offerings that include their delicious hoagies.

Since Thursday, June 29 marks the 25th anniversary of Wawa Hoagie Day, a few Metro Philly staffers went on a lunchtime expedition to Wawa’s Broad and Walnut location and dished on their favorite hoagies. From meat-free to dairy-free to adding a little horseradish for an extra kick, you just might decide to change up your usual order.

Name: Aaron Jollay
Title: Copy Editor
Favorite Hoagie: “The roast beef shorti with swiss cheese, horseradish, lettuce, tomato, onions and spinach. The rich flavor and the horseradish really wakes you up.”

Name: Evan Macy
Title: Sports Editor
Favorite Hoagie: “Buffalo chicken steak without cheese, with grilled onions, lettuce, salt and pepper. I like the combination of the spicy buffalo sauce — I happen to really like Wawa’s — with the buttery caramelized onions, a little spice diffusion and crunch from the lettuce and salt and pepper to intensify the chicken flavor. It’s messy, so hard to eat while driving, but I do it anyway (my clothes pay the price sometimes) en route to work quite often.”

Name: Jennifer Logue
Title: Philly Features Editor
Favorite Hoagie: “My go-to is a turkey hoagie with spinach, tomato, onion and spicy mustard — usually on a whole wheat roll but sometimes I’ll change it up with a classic roll. I try to avoid dairy on days that I sing so the robust flavor of the spinach paired with the zestiness of the mustard makes me forget about missing cheese!”

Name: Susan Peiffer
Title: Associate Publisher
Favorite Hoagie: “I get a cheese shorti hoagie with pepper jack and provolone on a whole wheat roll with lettuce, tomatoes, roasted and hot peppers, oil and vinegar. Sometimes I’ll add honey mustard too. Since I’m a vegetarian, this is my only Wawa hoagie option.”

Name: Jennifer Lydon
Title: Account Manager, Healthcare
Favorite Hoagie: “Tuna on toasted wheat with lettuce, tomato and onion. The tomato and onion livens it up and the crisp lettuce gives it a nice crunch.”

Name: David Williams
Title: Account Executive
Favorite Hoagie: “Chicken salad with lettuce, tomato, swiss, sweet or hot peppers depending on my mood. I love chicken salad, but as the feathered inferior to tuna, it cannot be trusted at other eateries, where I think it sits around for days.  But not at Wawa.  They’re shoveling it out by the minute!”

Name: Jennifer Fisher
Title: Account Executive, Classifieds
Favorite Hoagie: “Tuna on wheat with lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles and cucumbers. I have limited options because [I don’t eat meat] but I’d choose this regardless.”

So what are your favorite Wawa hoagies? Tell us in the comments below so we know what to eat for lunch next time!

More from our Sister Sites