A major disconnect between Drexel University and the Academy of Natural Sciences became public Monday, as representatives from both institutions presented differing timelines and budgetary amounts during a City Council hearing.
The Academy’s beloved 198-year-old museum on the Benjamin Franklin Parkway closed in September with less than a month’s notice, sparking an outcry from scientists, teachers, parents and others who valued the mounted dinosaur skeletons, wildlife dioramas and other exhibits.
During a retreat in September 2025, Academy board members presented the museum’s closure “as unpreventable and inevitable” and proposed moving the organization’s 19 million specimens to Cleveland or Abu Dhabi, Drexel President Antonio Merlo told lawmakers.
“In response, I made it clear this was unacceptable, and Drexel wanted no part of any plan to remove the academy’s treasures from the city of Philadelphia,” added Merlo, who was appointed in July 2025.
Academy board members claimed Merlo moved to cut off the school’s financial assistance, endangering the institution’s scientific research and collections departments, in addition to the museum.
At the same retreat, Merlo “basically said, ‘Look, you all need to move your collections and sell the building within two years,” Academy board chair Suzanne Biemiller testified. “That was information that was, obviously, upsetting to the trustees.”
In a sign of hope for supporters of the museum, City Councilmember Isaiah Thomas, who chaired Monday’s hearing, indicated that lawmakers are interested in making a multi-year funding pledge to the Academy. Money could be set aside as soon as the end of the year, he added.
Drexel has sought to renegotiate the affiliation agreement that has governed the relationship between the organizations since 2011. Former U.S. ambassador to Canada and Comcast executive David L. Cohen has been mediating those closed-door discussions for months on behalf of Gov. Josh Shapiro and Mayor Cherelle Parker.
However, talks appear to have stalled; the sides have not met since Oct. 2, according to Merlo.
Merlo accused the Academy board of walking away from a deal that they had initially signed onto in September 2026. The agreement would have granted Drexel full control of the Academy, with the board continuing in an advisory capacity.
Last month, the conversation moved toward a divorce. Drexel offered to continue back-office services during a disaffiliation transition, while Academy leaders asked for $5 million annually for five years to allow it to transform into an independent entity.
“We are facing a very dire financial situation ourselves,” Merlo said. “We would be delighted to see somebody else come to the table and provide the cash that right now Drexel cannot afford.”
Drexel officials stated that the museum ran a $4.6 million deficit for the fiscal year that ended in June. However, Biemiller said the board believes the shortfall, for a five-day-a-week operation, is less than $1 million a year.
“Reopening the museum will require much more money than what has been reported in the media,” Merlo remarked. “Tens of millions of dollars are needed to create a sustainable operating model, including undertaking major capital repairs, providing dependable operating support, and supporting a museum program that gives people a reason to visit and come back.”
Near the end of Monday’s four-hour hearing, Councilmember Rue Landau announced that Drexel and the Academy board had agreed to reconcile those numbers and report back to lawmakers by Dec. 1.
Thomas referred to suspicions that Drexel may be pursuing a “land grab.” University representatives said the Parkway property, which opened in 1876, was assessed last year for between $21 and $23 million.
At one point, Councilmember Jeffrey Young Jr, whose district includes the building, held up a large binder, which he said contained hundreds of pages of documents requested by the legislative body. Drexel provided the information less than two hours before the start of the hearing, he added.
Council issued subpoenas to Merlo and Deputy Mayor Trish Wellenbach, who Parker has loaned to the Academy as a senior advisory, after both did not testify at an initial hearing about the closure in late October.
Wellenbach on Monday referred most questions to Drexel and the Academy, telling them her three-month appointment is primarily to aid in the shutdown of the museum. She did say that funders will want to see the institutions finalize their governance structure and put out a plan before investing large amounts of money.
On Saturday, Drexel and the Academy announced that they would participate in feasibility studies paid for by a group of local foundations. A committee will oversee the process, and public input will be incorporated, officials said. Results could take up to a year, according to the statement.
Advocacy for the museum has not slowed down. Fans of the Academy again packed Council chambers and offered emotional testimony during the public comment portion of the meeting.
MORE: City Council presses officials over property tax assessments