A City Council committee, heeding the calls of Chester community leaders and environmental activists, moved Wednesday to end Philadelphia’s relationship with a Delaware County incinerator, against the wishes of Mayor Cherelle Parker’s administration.
Lawmakers amended the city’s waste disposal contract to cut out Reworld, which operates the nation’s largest waste-to-energy incinerator along the Delaware River, near the Philadelphia Union soccer complex.
The Parker administration had put forward a proposal that would have continued sending about 30% of municipal waste to the plant for at least four more years, with the option of extending the deal for an additional three years.
Under the altered contract that advanced unanimously out of Council’s Committee on the Environment, City Hall is only authorized to ink agreement with two other companies — WM and Republic Services — that own landfills in Bucks and Berks counties, respectively.
A final vote before the full Council is expected next month, with the contract becoming effective in January. Multi-year agreements require legislative approval. Parker could sign the measure, veto it, or allow it to go into effect without her signature.
“We will consider all options,” Joe Grace, the mayor’s director of communications, said in a statement following the committee vote.
Sanitation Commissioner Crystal Jacobs Shipman testified that it would be “irresponsible” for Philadelphia to eliminate the Reworld incinerator while the plant’s two other main customers — Delaware County and New York City — continue sending garbage to Chester.
Delaware County has committed to weaning itself off the facility, according to elected leaders from Chester.
Parker administration officials did not dispute a figure provided by Councilmember Jamie Gauthier’s office that removing Reworld would cost the city $3 million a year. However, City Hall still expects to save about $5 million a year through an overall reduction in spending, compared to the current contract.
Jacobs Shipman and Carlton Williams, the city’s managing director, argued that there is no significant difference between the environmental impacts of landfilling and incineration. Philadelphia, they added, must invest in alternative methods of disposal.
Data presented by the administration indicated that Chester’s air quality is on par with, if not better than, Philadelphia and the surrounding region.
Parker has endorsed a bill, introduced by Councilmember Mark Squilla, that would usher in a new zero waste policy, with the goal of diverting 60% of garbage away from landfills and incinerators. No hearing has been held on the legislation.
Gauthier, who has long pushed for a break with Reworld, responded by saying that the city can embark on that planning process while cutting ties with the Chester facility.
During Monday’s hearing, Eric Bazis, who worked at the waste-to-energy plant for nearly 30 years, rising to the level of operations supervisor, told lawmakers that Reworld fired him three years ago for raising environmental concerns.
The plant is subject to regulations, but he testified that managers “gamed the system” by manipulating test results. For example, Bazis said, clean-burning piles were set aside and run through the boilers at inspection time.
Kim Bradford, an environmental manager at Reworld, characterized the allegations as “absolutely incorrect” and described the claims as Bazis’ attempt to bolster his ongoing lawsuit against the company.
“I believe Mr. Bazis more than I believe Reworld,” Gauthier replied.
Bazis received a subpoena from Council to appear at the meeting; Reworld unsuccessfully challenged the order in court.
Representatives from the company said emissions from the Chester incinerator fall below federal and state limits. Claims about human health effects from the plant are not backed by evidence, they argued. Gauthier, Chester municipal leaders and environmentalists countered that air monitors installed at the site cannot detect some toxins that may escape the plant.
Zulene Mayfield, chair of Chester Residents Concerned for Quality Living, or CRCQL, said she has seen the impact first-hand. Her neighbors have been dying of rare cancers in their 30s, 40s and 50s in what she described as an “environmental genocide in my community.”
Mayfield and CRCQL have been battling the incinerator since it opened in the early 1990s. Turning to the Reworld employees seated inside Council chambers, she vowed to follow them wherever they go in search of a new contract.
Proponents of ending the agreement with Reworld cite the plant as a textbook example of environmental racism. Chester’s population is 72% Black and nearly 30% fall under the federal poverty line, according to U.S. Census data.
Chester Health Commissioner Kristin Motley said the city has disproportionately high rates of asthma, infant mortality and other health problems. Pollution, from the incinerator and other sources, plays a major role, she added.
Advocates noted that any harmful chemicals that are emitted from the plant can blow into Philadelphia and other communities.
At the end of the four-and-a-half hour hearing, Gauthier, the committee’s chair, informed those in attendance that there was not enough support to move forward with the administration’s contract proposal. All six members voted in favor of amending the bill and advancing it to the full Council body, sans Reworld.
“We have ended our practice of burning trash in Chester,” Gauthier said, sparking celebrations in the crowd.
In November 2025, Gauthier’s Stop Trashing Our Air Act, which would prohibit the city from incinerating waste, was moved out of committee. However, the legislation was unable to garner enough support to bring to a final vote, amid pushback from the Parker administration.
“We have been clear for over a year that we won’t tolerate the toxic status quo,” Gauthier said in a statement. “At a time when municipalities across the nation are making greener choices, we won’t allow the City of Philadelphia to keep making our residents sick with air polluted with our own waste.”
MORE: Where asthma rates are highest in Philly