After 23 years locked up, family wants ‘Hoagie’ freed

After 23 years locked up, family wants ‘Hoagie’ freed
Michelle Gustafson

ANorth Philly family is hitting the streets Thursdayto protest their family member’s long incarceration for a murder they said he did not commit.

Jerome “Hoagie” Coffey, 46,has been behind bars for 23 years — since March 3, 1993. He and family members say he was inside building a crib when they heard shooting on the street.

“My nephew, he was just born. I was trying to put a crib together at the same time the dude got killed,” Coffey said in a call from a state prison in Houtzdale.

Johnny Moss, 24, died in a hail of gunfire that night in December 1992. A few months later, Coffey was arrested and charged with the murder.

Since then, Coffey has filed appeal after appeal. His conviction was upheldby the state Supreme Court in 2013.

RELATED:Philly urban farmer-activist wants all of North Philly to bloom

Now, hehas new evidence for an appeal:the just-unsealed indictment charging his former appeal attorney, Philly lawyer J. Michael Farrell, with money laundering and drug trafficking, which Coffey said supports his theory that Farrell was ineffective counsel.

His family will be protesting Thursday outside the DA’s office to draw attention to the case and to seek assistance from Philly prosecutors in finding justice.

“We don’t have a problem with Seth Williams,” Coffey said. “We have a problem with Lynne Abraham and the way she had assistant district attorneys conduct these cases.”

Coffey has had atough time in prison. He said hespent12 years in solitary beforebeing relocated to Houtzdale.

The state Department of Corrections did not respond to a request to confirmCoffey’s time in solitary, but attorney Bret Grote, legal director of the Pittsburgh-based Abolitionist Law Centerwas in touch with Coffey while he was in “the hole.”

“He was not racking up additional violations while he was in solitary confinement. It was really hard to pin down the original reason for holding him down there,” Grote said of Coffey’s stay in solitary — which Grote pointed out is considered torture by the United Nations.

RELATED:Former Comcast exec sentenced for upskirt pictures on SEPTA

“To serve a prison sentence for a crime you didn’t commit is unspeakable, and then to spend that time in the prison within the prison is just like a nightmare.”

What evidence does Coffey have of his innocence? Justhis word and that of his family members, several of whom testified at trial,that he was in the house working on the cribwhen Moss was killed.

But the prosecution case wasn’t exactly strong either.

One witness, Nemo Kennedy, told police Coffey confessed, saying,“We did Johnny… that’s just how the game goes.” On the stand,Kennedy amended that to“We did something,” then reversed himself again and said he was afraidof retribution, according to court documents. Coffey insists thatKennedy was a paid informant who helped homicide detectives pin the murder on him for financial gain.

As to why? Coffey doesn’t know, beyond assuming detectives wanted the case solved and knew Coffey alreadyhad a record.

Coffey’s twin sister Jeannesaid even justgetting her brotherrelocated to a prisoncloser to the family and their ailing mother would be a step forward.

“They robbed me of my brother,” Jeanne said, who recalled the heavy toll that solitary took on her brother’s mind.

“One time we went to visit him andhe just broke down crying. He was saying, ‘You just don’t know what they did to me.’”

More from our Sister Sites